Welcome to Hot Tomato Pizza
Hot Tomato Pizza, located in the heart of Fruita, Colorado, is a beloved dining gem where quality meets warmth. Specializing in unique, handcrafted pizzas and fresh salads, the restaurant has earned rave reviews for its thin crust and flavorful ingredients. Diners appreciate the inviting atmosphere, enhanced by friendly staff who genuinely enjoy their craft. Whether indulging in a classic cheese slice or a creative pesto pizza, guests are met with attentive service and a laid-back vibe. Outdoor seating offers a perfect backdrop for enjoying the evening, making it a must-visit spot for locals and travelers alike.
-
124 N Mulberry St, Fruita, CO 81521, United States Hotline: +1 970-858-1117
Welcome to Hot Tomato Pizza, nestled in the charming town of Fruita, Colorado. Located at 124 N Mulberry St, this delightful pizza joint has quickly garnered a reputation for its mouthwatering offerings and inviting atmosphere. The moment you step inside, you're greeted by the warm smiles of the staff, creating a vibrant yet laid-back environment that invites you to sit back and savor every bite.
The defining feature of Hot Tomato is undoubtedly its pizza: handcrafted with passion and quality ingredients. Customers rave about the unique flavor profiles, like the pesto pizza that leaves a lasting impression with its fresh ingredients and perfectly balanced taste. You’ll find creative options like the Icarus pizza, iconic for its flavorful old-world pepperonis and an exceptional crust that has even the most discerning crust-critics schmoozing with delight. Christine Miller best captures this sentiment, describing the crust as “crispy, fresh, and full of bold flavor.”
Beyond their sensational pizzas, the menu also features delectable salads, such as the Beet Street salad, which perfectly combines greens, beets, and candied nuts, all drizzled with a balsamic dressing that elevates this dish to new heights. Grayson K enthusiastically notes that it’s “a perfect combo” that is not to be missed.
The experience at Hot Tomato extends beyond just the food. Diners frequently mention the warm and friendly service, enhancing your visit from the moment you walk in. Whether you're solo like Katie Stearns or dining with friends after exploring the beautiful Colorado National Monument, the ambiance is comforting, with soft reggae tunes setting the mood. Locals and travelers alike are treated to attentive service that feels genuine, making you feel right at home.
Hot Tomato Pizza has become a must-visit spot for anyone in Fruita. The combination of delectable dishes, friendly staff, and a warm atmosphere makes it a standout. Whether you're enjoying a cheese slice that shines in its simplicity or indulging in a creatively topped pizza, you're in for an unforgettable culinary experience. Don't forget to sit outside on a cool evening—it's an experience that can't be beaten!
As you plan your next culinary adventure, make sure to stop by Hot Tomato Pizza. With its captivating history, expertly crafted menu, and engaging staff, this spot will surely leave you raving just like the many satisfied customers before you. Call ahead at +1 970-858-1117 and prepare yourself for an extraordinary pizza experience!
Hot tomatoes is great and always worth the wait. Staff are helpful and the pizza and salad are fantastic. Sitting outside in the evening can't be beat!
What a gem! We showed up near closing (after checking out sunset at the Colorado National Monument) but we were welcomed warmly. The service was friendly and fast. Our pesto pizza came out quickly and was very delicious. The wine was also delicious and generously poured. The atmosphere was warm but vibrant and the store has an interesting history. We tried to go back on the other end of May our road trip but they were sadly closed on Sunday evenings. Will be back!
Rolled into Hot Tomato solo, close to closing, expecting to feel awkward—pizza joints like this usually buzz with big energy. But instead? No weird vibes. No rush. Just reggae low in the background. I got the cheese slice—because if you can’t get that right, what are we even doing? They got it right. Chewy crust, sauce that tastes like someone gave a damn, and cheese that’s rich, melty, and exactly what I was hoping for. The staff? Not fake-friendly—just cool. Like they rode all day, then strolled into the kitchen still sun-warmed and smiling. Fast, easygoing, and genuinely kind. The kind of people who’d help you fix a flat and hand you a slice. Hot Tomato’s not trying to impress anyone. That’s exactly why it does.
Pizza by the slice is nice and fast and rather good. Cooked well done which is awesome. Amazing staff just killing it! Especially Brooke!!
Fast and easy. Pizza slices are big and worth it. Even the little salad is enough for most. Got a slice and little pizza. More than enough for me. Both were great. Staff is friendly and attentive.
I’ve wanted to try this place for years after hearing nothing but great things. After a big lunch here, I certainly understand the praise. Unique pizzas that are clearly thoughtfully crafted (lemon zest crust?!). Friendly and attentive service and a really welcoming and comfortable atmosphere. I’ll be raving about it like the others and I’ll be back!
Hot Tomato did not disappoint this new local. Their thin crust pizza is absolutely delicious—crispy, fresh, and full of bold flavor. Every bite tastes like it was made with care. The vibe here is just as awesome as the food. The staff is super friendly and genuinely happy, which makes the whole experience feel fun and welcoming. It’s clear they love what they do, and that energy fills the place. If you’re in Fruita, this spot is a must-visit. I’ll definitely be coming back again and again!
This was phenomenal. Ashton took our order and it was delightful- super helpful, checked in at just the right times and was one of the best servers we've had in a while. Now the FOOD! My goodness. We got the Beet Street salad (perfect combo of greens, beets, candied nuts) and with the balsamic, chefs kiss. The Icarus pizza was awesome. Great old world pepperonis, veggies and THE CRUST! I'm not a crust person, for normal (aka non stuffed or flavored crust), this is the best I've had in a loooong time. We have starred this for future road trips. Love love this restaurant. Thank you!